CSM on Guantanamo

rob · #21 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 12:16 PM

I have said this before, until more information about the detainees is known they stay. If they are innocent then release them but only if they are found to be innocent. As far as the hunger strikes, let them die or starve. The detainees are living better than they would in their own countries and treated better that the people the terrorists capture.

Sam · #22 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 12:43 PM

Well that is the entire point. Let the information and hearings be known. Free innocents and deal with the guilty. Anyway Democratic and Republican contenders for the Whitehouse all are against Guatananmo as it is.

Did you read what Powell and McCain had to say about it?

Smitty0311 · #23 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Areyouforreal

I agree that

But don't you think that holding people and not trying them to see if they are terrorists is wrong?

If we had a trial for every pow in the war on terror it would greatly slow down progress! I can not tell you the number of mujahadien that my squad has captured detained and sent away! They all were beyond a shadow of a doubt guilty or caught in the act weather they were shooting at us or having stock piles of wepons and explosives in their home! A trial for terror is just the liberals way of slowing down progress just to make the situation look worse. I cant even explain to you the surge in violence in iraq that happend after the liberals made a big stink about this! How many troops dies just because the liberals motovate these terrorists. And if you dont think that liberals motovate terror you need to watch this video! Of an english speaking terrorists who works propaganda for al queda. We need to be one nation backing this war!
http://video.yahoo.com/video/play?p=...a%26ei%3DUTF-8

Sam · #24 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 04:35 PM

Smitty this is not about YOU your squad or who you caught. This is about a prison in Cuba. The foreign policy issues at hand are more complex than just YOU andYOUR SQUAD . Your input is part of it just as everyone is but just because someone disagrees with you does not mean they are a terrorist. In fact most of the introspective members who have served in the military here of all different political ideaology sound nothing like you.You could not even comprehend my thread on Sadr taking over medical care facilities and writing about was the result of research showing Shia militias had taken over healthcare facilities and that was why most physicians had fled and supported our military in raiding them. It was all lost on you .I was explaining why our military had to target healthcare facilities and you went on to call that propaganda and crap in one breath and then say your wild tales that actually backed up the very point I was making. Are you ok?

Anyway Smitty fortunately Republican and Democrats outside of this administration understand if we claim to hold the moral superiority on human rights Guatanamo needs dealt with. Prisoners are not in a battleground but held for years with no charges. I am sure in the heat of battle no one is saying have a trial.
Do you even read the threads before you post?

Smitty0311 · #25 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sam

Smitty this is not about YOU your squad or who you caught. This is about a prison in Cuba. The foreign policy issues at hand are more complex than just YOU andYOUR SQUAD . Your input is part of it just as everyone is but just because someone disagress with you does not mean they are a terrorist. In fact most of the introspective members who have served in the military here of all different political ideaology sound nothing like you.You could not even comprehend my thread on Sadr taking over medical care facilities and writing about was the result of research showing Shia militias had taken over healthcare facilities and that was why most physicians had fled and supported our military was raiding them. It was all lost on you .I was explaining why our military had to target healthcare facilities and you went on to call that propaganda in one breath and then say your wild tales that actually backed up the point I was making. Are you ok?

Wow your jumping all over the place arent you. vent Sam vent. Let it all out! It will be ok!

Anyway Smitty fortunately Republican and Democrats outside of this administration understand if we claim to hold the moral superiority on human rights Guatanamo needs dealth with. Prisoners are not in a battleground but held for years with no charges. I am sure in the heat of battle no one is saying have a trial. do you even read the threads before you post?

Now i will answer the question that is current in this thread. We did catch a number of HVT's (Vigh value targets) as well as big players in terrorism. After all Ar Ramadi was the stageing point for Falluja at the time and currently the most dangerous city in Iraq! What do you think we did to these people? We detained them and sent them off. We cought them red handed and we sent them packing. To where you ask? Think...............

And you want to disrupt the war on terror just to give these guys a trial? Look at that video again! Its every liberals speech to the american people spoken by a terrorist! http://video.yahoo.com/video/play?p=...a%26ei%3DUTF-8

Sam · #26 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 04:49 PM

There is paperwork on every detainee and some were sent and caught redhanded and others were just sent with no charges. If they are guilty then have a hearing if not make a decision. What country do you think the detainees are from Smitty?Do you know?

Smitty0311 · #27 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sam

There is paperwork on every detainee and some were sent and caught redhanded and others were just sent with no charges. If they are guilty then have a hearing if not make a decision. What country do you think the detainees are from Smitty?Do you know?

Many countrys!

Sam · #28 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 05:02 PM

Specifically which countries,who detained them and what were they caught doing? I found out that from our military and other studies. You seem to state you captured some and sent them to Cuba. Could you elaborate on that story?

I think some are terribly guilty and it is clear. It would be easy to have a hearing. Others well I will wait to hear from you just what countries they were taken from and who captured them.

I think I agree with Powell and McCain careful considerations(not Smitty) on our methods for detainment as making us hypocrites in our high standards and endangering our troops. Okay I will wait to hear who and where you captured people that are in Guatanamo.Please name the country you were in and the city. How many were sent?

Smitty0311 · #29 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 05:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sam

Specifically which countries,who detained them and what were they caught doing? I found out that from our military and other studies. You seem to state you captured some and sent them to Cuba. Could you elaborate on that story?

I think some are terribly guilty and it is clear. It would be easy to have a hearing. Others well I will wait to hear from you just what countries they were taken from and who captured them.

I think I agree with Powell and McCain careful considerations(not Smitty) on our methods for detainment as making us hypocrites in our high standards and endangering our troops. Okay I will wait to hear who and where you captured people that are in Guatanamo.Please name the country you were in and the city. How many were sent?

Im sorry if you want to prove a point then you find this information out for yourself. These people are detained from all over the world and sometimes handed to us from other goverments. Good luck and happy hunting!

Here is something for ya! http://en.rian.ru/russia/20051025/41890783.html coencedence?

oceanbreeze · #30 (**permalink**) 01-14-2007, 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sam

Smitty this is not about YOU your squad or who you caught. This is about a prison in Cuba. The foreign policy issues at hand are more complex than just YOU andYOUR SQUAD . Your input is part of it just as everyone is but just because someone disagrees with you does not mean they are a terrorist. In fact most of the introspective members who have served in the military here of all different political ideaology sound nothing like you.You could not even comprehend my thread on Sadr taking over medical care facilities and writing about was the result of research showing Shia militias had taken over healthcare facilities and that was why most physicians had fled and supported our military in raiding them. It was all lost on you .I was explaining why our military had to target healthcare facilities and you went on to call that propaganda and crap in one breath and then say your wild tales that actually backed up the very point I was making. Are you ok?

Anyway Smitty fortunately Republican and Democrats outside of this administration understand if we claim to hold the moral superiority on human rights Guatanamo needs dealt with. Prisoners are not in a battleground but held for years with no charges. I am sure in the heat of battle no one is saying have a trial.
Do you even read the threads before you post?

AMEN, SAM!