Quote:
Originally Posted by cat's meow
The free market system is basically a Western based conncept of supply and demand. It would truly work if:
- There were no political boundries
- All people had the same eduation and knowledge base
- All people believed in the same exact God, or all were atheist
- All people lived in the same climate
etc
|
No, the free market system is basically a HUMAN-devised system of, if you break it down, barter with little-to-know interference by outside parties such as government.
It can be as primitive as direct barter of goods and services for other goods and services or more advanced with the exhange of goods/services for somethng of par value (agreed to by parties, which can include state-issued notes or "money" or other things which are easily converted to such notes or easily traded in the place of such notes).
It has been the primary means of this sort of exchange since Oog first determined he could trade spear tips for mastadon meat without ever having himself to go on the hunt. Supply and demand kicks in when Oog's spear tips are so good at what they are intended to do, the herds are plentiful and the hunters with whom he trades are not utter morons, that the tribe grows, requiring more mastadon meat, obtained with Oog's speartips, which he then must make more of to keep up with demand.
Free market capitalism is not as complex and mysterious as leftists, Keynsians, Malthusians and other anti-Westerners want to believe.
Let's look at Kookie's anarchist's cookbook list here:
1. It's true that fewer boundaries of ANY kind encourage rather than discourage free market trade,
2. What on earth does this have to do with anything? And what does it mean: We should all be educated as physicists, or none of us should be educated beyond say a typical 8th grade (US) education? I am assuming Kookie believes that if you are better educated you will take advantage of the less educated. An odd argument and utterly without any basis in fact. Why is it necessary for Oog (in my example) to know where (knowledge base) the best mastadon hunting grounds are in order for him to make his spear tips, and if the hunters have the same ability as Oog to find good flint for knapping into speartips and can make the same quality tips themselves, why keep Oog around at all? And is this even possible: Can a 19 yr old HAVE the same knowledge as a graybeard? I know they all THINK they are smarter and know more than old men who "just don't get it," but is that really true?
3. What difference does this make? I migh worship rocks, and Oog might worship trees. Does this mean we can't talk mastadons and speartips with one another and if so, why?
4. I can't even imagine why anyone would believe this is necessary to free trade. The Innuit engaged in trade of furs and blubber with the Vikings who got wine from the Levant, whose people got silk from China, and gold from Africa....this makes no sense at all and bespeaks someone who is either incapable of thought or rarely engages in it.
5. Etc. Etc....what? This could mean anything! That everyone is the same hat size? That nobody is mentally or physically handicapped? That everyone had the same physical and intellectual ability? What does it mean? What are the limits? Are there any?
This is n00bery writ large.
People like Kookie should stick to keeping their heads insulated in that special way they do, and leave the mysteries of thought to others more qualified.
Tokie