Originally Posted by Dom1

Their indivual numbers are pretty good.

I would take Jeter's numbers over Eckstein's.
And Damon's (or Williams four years ago) over Edmonds.
And Posada over Matheny or Molina's.
And Soriano/Cano's over Vina/second base by committee.
And Matsui over RF by committee.

The Yankee pitching is what holds them back.